Who’s afraid of bedbugs? In emergency shelter, that’d be everybody – Generocity
Scabies, lice, and bedbugs dont care if were in the midst of a COVID-19 pandemic.
But some of the strategies weve been using to prevent COVID-19 transmission in shelter are relevant to these other, longstanding public health threats.
In a previous article, I described how Bethesda Projects Church Shelter Program has been using a form of community-based surveillance (CBS) in response to COVID-19. Recently, I took a closer look at CBS initiatives in Cuba, Uganda, and Ecuador to learn how other communities in resource-limited settings creatively and effectively respond to disease outbreaks. Then, using some of their best practices, I designed a community-based model of pest prevention for use in our shelter.
In this article, Ill share what I learned and say more about this model (which is flexible enough to be used in other shelters or congregate settings).
The 1978 Alma-Ata declaration of the World Health Organization states that governments have a responsibility for the health of their people. Ive written before about how the Church Shelter Program operates with a governance rather than a management paradigm, so we hold ourselves accountable to this statement. What it means to us is that shelter staff have a responsibility to proactively protect our guests from diseases associated with shelter settings.
In the context of pests such as scabies, lice and bed bugs, it means that we proactively work to prevent outbreaks and swiftly address them if they do occur. To ignore such an outbreak, or claim that the affected guests are responsible for dealing with it on their own, would be a violation of their right to health and of our responsibility as shelter providers.
At the same time, it also matters to give members of the shelter community the opportunity to design and participate in public health measures intended to benefit them.
Cuba happens to have a long history of community involvement in public health efforts, as described by Dr. Linda M. Whiteford and Dr. Laurence G. Branch in Primary Health Care in Cuba: The Other Revolution (2009). For example, in the 1960s the Cuban government successfully trained ordinary citizens to administer vaccines for measles, chicken pox, and polio, which enabled widespread vaccination campaigns to rapidly occur across the island.
Following an outbreak of dengue fever in the early 1980s, Cuba took a similar approach. Neighborhood brigades composed of ordinary citizens were trained to recognize and remove the plants that are hosts for the Aedes egypti mosquito (the vector responsible for transmitting dengue fever to humans). The brigades patrolled their communities even going into their neighbors yards to remove plants, pick up trash, spray insecticide, and eliminate standing water that could serve as breeding grounds for mosquitos. Within four months, Cuba had ended the outbreak.
This approach also proved valuable during the emergence of Zika virus. In a 2017 article published in The American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, researchers noted that at a time when Brazil had 200,465 cases of Zika, Colombia had 95,793, Venezuela had 58,591, Martinique had 36,445, and Honduras had 31,468, Cuba had just 3 cases. They attribute Cubas success with limiting Zika transmission to the countrys culture of active community participation in mosquito control efforts.
In a 2018 article in the journal Nature, Sara Reardon describes how even before any cases of Zika were detected on the island, Cuba dispatched soldiers to begin spraying homes with insecticide, health workers conducted surveillance for mosquito larvae near water sources, and medical officials went door-to-door to conduct symptom screenings. And yet, Reardon is also clear that Cubas success here was largely because of such intensive measures by ordinary citizens, people who did not have advanced or medical degrees.
Uganda took a similar approach in its Guinea Worm Eradication Program, established 1991 as a collaboration between the Ugandan Ministry of Health, The Carter Center, and UNICEF. Guinea worm disease is a parasitic infection that is transmitted when humans consume water contaminated with guinea worm larvae. In 1991, at the start of the eradication effort, Uganda registered over 126,000 cases. By 2004, the disease had been eliminated within its borders.
A 2006 article published in the American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene describes one community-based approach that helped achieve this outcome: Elderly men in local communities were recruited to act as pond caretakers. These were typically men who were respected by their peers and who were too old to engage in farm work, but who were fully capable of monitoring the communitys water supply to ensure it was not contaminated with guinea worm larvae.
The pond caretakers gathered water for visitors, provided filter straws to individuals who came to drink from the ponds directly, and created fences or barriers around the ponds.
Clearly, community involvement makes a difference but is it actually necessary?
Yes, it is.
The Cuban Minister of Health may know the species of plants that are hosts for the Aedes egypti mosquito, but she doesnt know whether or not those plants are growing in your yard, let alone where in the yard but you do, and your neighbor certainly does. The Ugandan Minister of Health may know that guinea worm disease is transmitted by water, but he doesnt know where every single pond in your community is but you do, and your neighbors certainly do as well.
Specialists, experts, and clinicians have an important role to play in designing and coordinating public health responses, but effective on-the-ground implementation depends on communities themselves.
Dr. Whiteford explores this point in depth in her book Community Participatory Involvement (2015), which describes lessons learned from a community-based intervention to contain a cholera epidemic in rural Ecuador.
Local experiences and knowledge were crucial to the success of the intervention because while the methods to address cholera may be simple i.e. boiling water and handwashing their implementation was not.
In certain parts of Ecuador at the time, many households did not have plumbing. Boiling water to purify it meant having to get extra wood or charcoal, which households could not afford. Asking people to wash their hands more often meant having to manually transport more water from the river to the household.
Meanwhile, the use of the soap created a new set of problems. For example, like many people in water-scarce communities, people in this region used one container of water for cooking, rising dishes, washing hands, and then finally feeding livestock. However, the soap altered the taste of the water and the livestock refused to drink it, which threatened the families livelihood.
It was only by including community members in the response to cholera that researchers were able to effectively navigate these obstacles.
With the insights and experiences from Cuba, Uganda and Ecuador in mind, here is what my model of community-based pest prevention in emergency shelter looks like.
Shelter guests will be the first to recognize or suspect that an outbreak of pests lets say, bedbugsis occurring because they are the ones who sleep in the shelter. This also means they are well-positioned to report suspected outbreaks early on.
Within the shelter community, peers have unique levels of social capital, legitimacy, and trust amongst each other. In addition, they also have local knowledge that is important for addressing bed bugs. For example, they know which mattress covers have tears, which sleeping mats are beginning to fray, where the cracks in the walls are, which person is hiding stashes of clutter, which guys have bites on their arms, etc.
These are crucial details that mean the difference between containing a bedbug outbreak or not.
To make use of the social capital, insights, and knowledge of the shelter community, we need to create a culture of community-based pest prevention. To do that,shelter staff and guests collaborate to select a small subset of guests who are recognized for consistently stepping up to help with cleaning, housekeeping, etc. These are individuals who are attentive, observant, respected by their peers, and who place a high value on cleanliness.
These individuals are then invited to act as pest monitors who will inspect the shelters beds, cots, or sleeping mats every day for signs of bedbugs. The monitors will be trained in the basic biology of bedbugs, indicators of infestations, and risk factors for infestation.
Shelter staff and guests will then collaborate to decide on a range of early intervention measures that the monitors will have the autonomy to apply (i.e. laundering bedding and clothes, treating furniture with a portable steam cleaner; vacuuming bed seams, etc.).
As I wrote in a previous column, the long-term solution to disease outbreaks in shelter is to ensure that there is no need for shelters in the first place. Providing people with safe, adequate, affordable housing, perhaps with support services, is the best way to reduce their risk of contracting a contagious disease in congregate settings.
But, while we do have shelters and while people are residing in them, we have a responsibility to keep them clean and safe. One of the most powerful and effective ways we can do that is to involve shelter guests themselves in the public health interventions designed for these settings.
Get stories like this daily in your inbox
Read the original post:
Who's afraid of bedbugs? In emergency shelter, that'd be everybody - Generocity
- Woman's TUI bedbug horror as bed sheets covered in bugs blood as one 'crawls in friend's ear' - The Mirror - October 12th, 2024
- What to Know About Bed Bugsand How to Avoid Them While Traveling - AFAR Media - October 12th, 2024
- Las Vegas hotel bed bugs leave tourist with permanent scarring, lawsuit says - KLAS - 8 News Now - October 10th, 2024
- Freaked Out First-Class Passenger Had a Bed Bug Climbing Their Leg - VICE - October 10th, 2024
- Do We Have to Worry About Bedbugs on Flights Now? - Thrillist - October 10th, 2024
- 5 Easy Ways To Get Rid Of Bedbugs - WION - October 10th, 2024
- Where inspectors found bed bugs, no hand washing, moldy wastewater in Topeka - The Topeka Capital-Journal - October 8th, 2024
- If you want to kill bed bugs for good you have to wash them at this specific temperature - The Mirror - October 8th, 2024
- Cleaning expert swears by 65p kitchen cupboard ingredient to kill bedbugs - The Mirror - October 8th, 2024
- What Not to Do When Bed Bugs Invade - MSN - October 6th, 2024
- Heres How to Identify Bed Bug Bites and How to Treat Them - Prevention Magazine - October 4th, 2024
- Madison Metro reports bed bug found on bus the day of BRT launch in September - WKOW - October 4th, 2024
- Davenport Named One Of The Most Bed Bug Infested Cities In The U.S. - B100 - October 2nd, 2024
- Company: No bed bugs at theater - Sandusky Register - October 2nd, 2024
- Brits ignoring 'key step' in hygiene which will keep bed bugs away amid infestation - The Mirror - October 2nd, 2024
- 'I'm a pharmacist - here's what to do if you're bitten by bed bugs' - The Mirror - October 2nd, 2024
- Our 30th wedding anniversary in the Canary Islands was ruined by bed bugs - now we're taking legal action - Daily Mail - September 30th, 2024
- Bed bugs spotted at theater? - Norwalk Reflector - September 28th, 2024
- How to Get Rid of Boxelder Bugs and Keep Them Away from Your Home - Better Homes & Gardens - September 28th, 2024
- Bed bugs spotted at theater? - Sandusky Register - September 26th, 2024
- Bed bug discovery leads to another Michigan library closing temporarily - MLive.com - September 26th, 2024
- Oak Park Public Library expected to reopen tomorrow following pest-related closure - WXYZ 7 Action News Detroit - September 26th, 2024
- The first thing you should do in your hotel room - ABC4.com - September 26th, 2024
- Bed bugs on the rise in Ireland - Beat 102-103 - September 25th, 2024
- How to spot if you have bedbugs: They look like an apple pip - Newstalk - September 25th, 2024
- Understand what youre working with in order to defeat your bed bug problem - Pest Management Professional magazine - September 23rd, 2024
- Big surge in bed bug infestations across Ireland down to Paris Olympics as cases expected to last up to C... - The Irish Sun - September 23rd, 2024
- Tales from the Trenches: Field Implementation of Aprehend for Bed Bug Management - PCT Online - September 21st, 2024
- News5 viewers bring bed bug problem at the Pueblo Rescue Mission to our attention - KOAA News 5 - September 21st, 2024
- Bedbugs found in 10 beds at Hong Kong's public hospital, with 4 patients believed to have been bitten - Hong Kong Free Press - September 21st, 2024
- Bedbugs and mattress disposal problem costing Youngstown taxpayers - WFMJ - September 19th, 2024
- Bedbugs and city mattress disposal problem costing taxpayers - WFMJ - September 19th, 2024
- Easton Housing Authority wont wait for tenants to report bedbugs. Regular checks are in place. - lehighvalleylive.com - September 19th, 2024
- How did bedbugs end up in Hong Kong hospital and how can we avoid infestations? - South China Morning Post - September 19th, 2024
- California Department of Education building dealing with potential bed bug infestation - KCRA Sacramento - September 15th, 2024
- Bed Bugs in Schools Zoom - University of NebraskaLincoln - September 15th, 2024
- Insights on diagnosing and treating scabies, bedbugs, and lice effectively - News-Medical.Net - September 12th, 2024
- JJs Thats Awesome: From Bed Bugs To Grateful Hugs - KFDI - September 10th, 2024
- Chillicothe movie theater addresses bedbug concerns - Scioto Valley Guardian - September 10th, 2024
- What are renters rights when dealing with bed bugs? - FOX 31 Denver - September 5th, 2024
- Real-life computer bugs? Student Chromebooks infested with bedbugs - and it's not the first time - ZDNet - September 5th, 2024
- What rights Colorado renters have when it comes to bed bugs FOX31 Denver - FOX 31 Denver - September 5th, 2024
- Bed bug bites: How to identify them, get relief, and prevent future ... - September 3rd, 2024
- Students' Chromebooks infested with bedbugs - KOMO News - September 3rd, 2024
- Bed Bugs in Houston - UT Physicians - September 3rd, 2024
- Ex-Trump voters reveal why theyve dumped Trump: Like a mattress with bed bugs - MSNBC - September 1st, 2024
- Bed bugs spread worse than a forest fire What to do as a renter when your apartment is infested - Monadnock Ledger Transcript - September 1st, 2024
- How to kill bed bugs with this common 65p household item - Metro.co.uk - September 1st, 2024
- Does Your Illinois Destination Have Bed Bugs? See Recent Reports - KHMO News-Talk-Sports - September 1st, 2024
- Toddler girl starved in apartment filled with bed bugs and feces, police say - MLive.com - August 29th, 2024
- Housing Authority tenants filed more than 4,000 complaints about bed bugs and pests. Now they are suing. - Milwaukee Journal Sentinel - August 29th, 2024
- Georgia family receives full refund after finding bedbugs all over Florida vacation rental - 11Alive.com WXIA - August 29th, 2024
- My fight to survive bed bugs in Baltimore | GUEST COMMENTARY - Baltimore Sun - August 29th, 2024
- Residents and Common Ground sue HACM over "uninhabitable" living conditions, bed bugs - WTMJ - August 29th, 2024
- 'Imagine them crawling in my ear': Housing Authority residents sign on to bedbug lawsuit - Spectrum News 1 - August 29th, 2024
- Tenants sue Housing Authority of the City of Milwaukee over 'uninhabitable' living conditions - TMJ4 News - August 29th, 2024
- PCT Awards Gift Cards to Bed Bug Survey Participants - PCT Online - August 28th, 2024
- Dangerous mosquito-borne illness detected in the U.S. do Canadians need to worry? Plus more bugs to know about - Yahoo Canada Shine On - August 28th, 2024
- With bed bugs in an apartment, tenants can lose it all and foot the extermination bill - Concord Monitor - August 25th, 2024
- Human feces. Bed bugs. Crystal meth. And tons of junk. Shadowing the crew of Merica JunkBoss - The Times of Northwest Indiana - August 25th, 2024
- 5 Smells Bed Bugs Absolutely Hate - MSN - August 25th, 2024
- The Best Mattress and Pillow Protectors and Encasements | Reviews by Wirecutter - The New York Times - August 25th, 2024
- Bed Bugs Discovered In Greeneville Walmart Restrooms - WGRV.com - August 24th, 2024
- Bed bugs. Human feces. Crystal meth. And tons of junk. Shadowing the crew of Merica JunkBoss. - The Times of Northwest Indiana - August 24th, 2024
- Madison metro received 13 bed bug complaints since June; city records show all were addressed within 24 hours - WMTV - August 24th, 2024
- Brits urged to lookout for bed bugs abroad - how to spot them in your hotel - Yahoo News UK - August 24th, 2024
- Britons warned over bed bugs abroad - and how to spot them - Express - August 24th, 2024
- How I spent $4,700 on my first trip abroad to Paris and London and what I'd try next time to save money and avoid bed bugs - Business Insider - August 21st, 2024
- This Texas City Is Ranked As The Third Most Bed Bug Infested City in America - News/Talk 790 KFYO - August 21st, 2024
- Bed bugs or fleas? How to tell whats biting you in bed - Tom's Guide - August 20th, 2024
- Best temperature to kill bacteria and bed bugs when washing bedding - and it's not 60C - Express - August 20th, 2024
- Disney Releases Official Response As Ongoing Bed Bug Crisis Infests Parks - Inside the Magic - August 20th, 2024
- Metro Transit responds to bed bug sightings on buses - Channel3000.com - WISC-TV3 - August 18th, 2024
- Get rid of bed bugs with pest controller's 'effective' method - 'kills their eggs' - Express - August 18th, 2024
- Two Texas Cities Among Most Bed Bug Infected in the U.S. - knue.com - August 18th, 2024
- People urged to check their beds especially if they have been on holiday - The Mirror - August 18th, 2024
- Free tertiary tuition for first years: The universities should get ready for a bedbug infestation Prof. Smart Sarpong jabs Mahama - Modern Ghana - August 18th, 2024
- Georgia family looking forward to Florida vacation find bedbugs all over rental. They're now fighting for a full refund. - 11Alive.com WXIA - August 16th, 2024
- Beware of bedbugs: How to deal with these pests - WRDW - August 16th, 2024
- KY and TN Cities Appear on Annual Most Bed Bugs List - WBKR - August 13th, 2024